西南石油大学学报(社会科学版)

• 法学 • 上一篇    下一篇

论我国重刑主义思潮下刑法谦抑性的时代性亮点

张腾龙   

  1. 山东大学法学院,山东济南250100
  • 出版日期:2015-03-01 发布日期:2015-03-01
  • 作者简介:张腾龙(1988 –),男(汉族),山东莱西人,硕士研究生,研究方向:宪法学、行政法学、刑法学。

The Value of Modesty and Restraint of Criminal Law in the Contemporary
Context of Severe Punishment Practice in China

Zhang Teng - long   

  1. Law School,Shandong University,Ji’nan Shandong,250100,China
  • Online:2015-03-01 Published:2015-03-01

摘要:

刑法谦抑性理论是现代刑法学中的一项重要理论,其具有紧缩性、经济性、补充性的价值蕴含。在我国两千
多年的封建历史中,重刑主义一直占据着法律思想的统治地位,在各种法律规范中,刑事法律一枝独秀。作为中国封
建法律典型代表的《唐律疏议》,在立法体例上以刑统律,在婚姻、债务、财产、继承、经济行政等方面均运用刑罚手段
予以调整。这种重刑主义传统对当代的司法实践也有着巨大的影响力,我国在1983 年、1996 年、2001 年实施的三次
以从重从快为特色的“严打”就体现了对重刑主义的崇拜。在制度层面上,1979 年刑法典规定了严重背离罪刑法定原
则的类推制度;目前我国刑法中可以适用死刑的罪名的比例仍远高于西方法治国家,重刑主义的倾向依然存在。《刑
法修正案(八)》一次性废除了走私文物罪等13 个非暴力型犯罪中的死刑,并对年满75 周岁的人犯罪予以从宽性刑
罚处罚,还规定了对未成年人犯罪不构成累犯和未成年人犯罪记录消除制度,这些规定都是刑法谦抑性理论的制度
成果。

关键词: 刑法谦抑性, 重刑主义, 《刑法修正案(八)》, 犯罪范围, 刑罚限度

Abstract:

The theory of modesty and restraint of criminal law is significant in contemporary criminal jurisprudence,which is
characteristic of minimization,economy and complementariness. In the more than 2,000 years of China’s history,the thought
of severe punishment has been dominated the legal ideology. And in a variety of legal norms,criminal law has been outshining
other law.Tang Code,the typical representative of law in feudal China,adopted criminal law system in legislative style,and
punishment was employed in aspects of marriage,debt,property,inheritance,economic administrative. Such ideology of
severe punishment has had a huge influence on contemporary judicial practice. The implementation of the“severe and quick”
punishment in 1983,1996 and 2001 are good examples of severe punishment ideology. At the institutional level,such example
can be seen in the Penal Code of 1979,which provided a clause of analogy,and seriously violated the principle of“no penalty
without a law”. Another example of the severe punishment ideology is the fact that the number of death penalty charges in
China stays at a much higher level than in western countries.The 8th Amendment to Criminal Law of People’s Republic of
China abolished death penalty in 13 kinds of nonviolent crimes such as the crime of smuggling of cultural relics. It also
provided lenient punishment to those culprits who are over 75 years,and no recidivism of juvenile delinquency and juvenile
crime records removal system. All those regulations are the results of the theory of modesty and restraint criminal law

Key words: restraining of criminal law;severe punishment ideology;the 8th Amendment to Criminal Law of People&rsquo, s Republic
of China;crime range;limits of criminal punishment