西南石油大学学报(社会科学版)

• 法学 • 上一篇    下一篇

论冷冻胚胎继承权的保护与限制——兼评我国首例冷冻胚胎继承权纠纷案

陈友平 丁伟   

  1. 西南政法大学民商法学院,重庆401120
  • 出版日期:2015-11-01 发布日期:2015-11-01
  • 通讯作者: 丁伟(1991 –),男(汉族),山东青岛人,硕士研究生,研究方向:知识产权法。
  • 作者简介:陈友平(1991 –),男(汉族),安徽省马鞍山人,硕士研究生,研究方向:民商法。

Protection and Restriction of Frozen Embryo’s Inheritance ——Comments on the First Dispute of Frozen Embryo’s Inheritance

Chen Youping  Ding Wei   

  1. Chen Youping, Ding Wei
  • Online:2015-11-01 Published:2015-11-01

摘要:

冷冻胚胎是在现代辅助生殖技术飞速发展过程中产生的,它是体外受精——胚胎移植技术应用的产物。在司
法实践中,法律对冷冻胚胎的法律性质、权利归属以及继承权缺乏相关的规定,由此导致了一系列的纠纷,亟需法律对
其有一个明确的定位。冷冻胚胎尽管具有孕育成生命的潜质,但因还未出生,依照我国《民法通则》的规定,其在法律
属性上不具备民事权利能力,不能成为民事法律关系的主体,因此只能是“物”。但是,冷冻胚胎不是一般的“物”,因
其具有孕育成生命的潜质,也就具有部分人格尊严的属性,应为具有人格权属性的特定伦理物。意欲成为父母而通过
手术产生冷冻胚胎的夫妻是冷冻胚胎的权利人,在权利人死亡后,其可以作为遗产被继承人所继承。但是,基于冷冻
胚胎具有孕育生命的潜质属性,其继承人享有的是受限制的管理和处分权。

关键词: 冷冻胚胎, 伦理物, 遗产, 继承权, 代孕

Abstract:

Frozen embryo came into existence in the rapid development of modern assisted reproductive technology as a
byproduct of in-vitro fertilization and embryo transplantation technology. In the practice of justice,a series of disputes occur
due to the absence of relevant laws and regulations on frozen embryo’s legal nature,its right owners and inheritance,which
urges a clear definition of frozen embryo’s legal status. Though the frozen embryo possesses the potential of becoming a solid
being,it hasn’t been born as a living being. On the one hand,according to the regulations of General Principles of Civil Law,
the frozen embryo does not have the capacity of rights and cannot be defined as the subject in civil legal relationship;it must be
an“object”. On the other hand,it cannot be simply defined as an ordinary“object”,but a specific ethical object which has the
potential to grow into a human being and therefore possess partial personality. The couple willing to be the parents by surgery
is the right owner of the frozen embryo. After the death of the right owners,the frozen embryo can be inherited as heritage
by the heir. However,due to its potential to become real living being,the heir only enjoys restricted right of supervision and
disposal to the frozen embryo.

Key words: frozen embryo, ethical object, legacy, inheritance, surrogacy

中图分类号: