西南石油大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2012, Vol. 14 ›› Issue (5): 63-68.DOI: 10.3863/j.issn.1674-5094.2012.05.012

• 政治学与法学 • 上一篇    下一篇

论商事惯例与司法规制间的博弈——以责任保险合同中免责条款的效力审查为视角

肖俊   

  1. 重庆市北碚区人民法院民二庭,重庆 400700
  • 收稿日期:1900-01-01 修回日期:1900-01-01 出版日期:2012-09-01 发布日期:2012-09-01

On the Game Between the Trading Convention and Judicial Regulations—From the Perspective of Investigation of the Effectiveness ofExemption Clause in Liability Insurance Contracts

XIAO Jun   

  1. Civil Court Trial Division II,People’s Court of Beibei District,Chongqing ,400700,China
  • Received:1900-01-01 Revised:1900-01-01 Online:2012-09-01 Published:2012-09-01

摘要: 我国保险免责条款之创制是商事惯例契约形式的集中体现,并亦为传统保险立法所接纳。随着“私法自治之社会化”理论的渐兴,对现代保险业也产生了深刻的影响,保险免责条款的相关理论也备受质疑。责任保险中,保险人滥用免责条款推卸给付责任之弊为人所重视。因此,有必要对责任保险免责条款进行司法审查。对责任保险免责条款的司法审查应以重塑最大诚信原则为指导,并将“不正当的不利”和“不恰当的失衡”作为保险法最大诚信原则具体化的两个要件,以此认定责任保险免责条款的效力。

关键词: 商事惯例, 保险法, 最大诚信原则, 责任保险, 免责条款

Abstract: In China,the creation of insurance exemption clause is the reflection of trading convention contract and it is also accepted by the traditional insurance legislation. The rising of the theory about “socialization of private law autonomy” has profoundly impacted modern insurance industry,and the relevant theory of insurance exemption clause is called into question. In the liability insurance contract,the shortcoming of insurer’s abuse of disclaimer to shift performance responsibility has been attached importance to. Therefore,it is necessary to seek judicial review for liability insurance exemption clauses,which should be guided by the principle of rebuilding the utmost good faith. “Unfair prejudice” and “inappropriate imbalance” should be taken as two concrete elements for the principle of utmost good faith within insurance law in identifing the effectiveness of exemption clauses of liability insurance.

Key words: trading convention, insurance law, principle of utmost good faith, liability insurance, exemption clause

中图分类号: