大理大学学报 ›› 2021, Vol. 6 ›› Issue (9): 1-10.DOI: 10. 3969 / j. issn. 2096-2266. 2021. 09. 001

• 特约稿 •    下一篇

创造性判断中公知常识认定研究

冯晓青,余子凯   

  1. 中国政法大学民商经济法学院
  • 出版日期:2021-09-15 发布日期:2021-10-25
  • 作者简介: 冯晓青,教授,博士生导师,主要从事知识产权法、知识产权管理与战略研究。
  • 基金资助:
     国家社会科学基金重大项目(17ZDA139)

Research on the Identification of Common Knowledge in Creativity Judgment#br#

Feng Xiaoqing, Yu Zika   

  1. School of Civil, Commercial and Economic Law, China University of Political Science and Law
  • Online:2021-09-15 Published:2021-10-25

摘要: 公知常识认定是创造性判断中的关键一环。在我国发明和实用新型专利审查实践中,公知常识的载体来源稍显单一,
传统书面载体的适用陷入“有心无力”的尴尬境地。此外,囿于公知常识说理论证的主观化风险,该举证模式的合理性基
础也颇受业界质疑。为提升公知常识认定的质量与效率,我国有必要适当扩张公知常识的载体外延,克服公知常识载体来
源限定式思维的既有弊端;与此同时,严格划定说理论证的适用语境,避免审查人员裁量权的滥用。公知常识认定与创造
性判断的理念和原理难以截然分开,正确解构公知常识规则的应有内容,应立足于创造性判断的基本制度框架,溯本求源,
把握二者的有机联系。

关键词: 公知常识, 专利法, 创造性, 认定规则, 公共领域

Abstract: Common knowledge identification is a key link in patent creativity judgment. In the practice of patent examination in
China, the source of the carrier of common knowledge is a little monotonous, and the application of the traditional written carrier
is in the awkward situation of incapability. In addition, limited by the risk of subjectivity in the reasoning and demonstrating of
common knowledge, the rationality basis of this proof model is also quite questioned by the industry. In order to improve the quality
and efficiency of common knowledge identification, it is necessary for China to appropriately expand the carrier scope of common
knowledge and overcome the existing drawbacks of the limited thinking of the source of common knowledge carrier. At the same time,
it is indispensable to strictly define the applicable context of common knowledges reasoning and demonstrating to avoid the improper
abuse of the discretion of the examiners. Common knowledge identification is closely related to the concept and principle of creativity
judgment. To correctly deconstruct the content of the common knowledge rules, we must start from the basic institutional framework
of creativity judgment, trace back to the origin of the institution and grasp the organic connection between the common knowledge
identification and creativity judgment.

Key words: common?knowledge, ?patent?law, ?creativity, ?identification?rules, ?public?domain

中图分类号: