西南石油大学学报(社会科学版)

• 法学 • 上一篇    下一篇

试论法条竞合的类型及其适用原则

陈楚君   

  1. 四川大学法学院,四川成都610225
  • 出版日期:2015-05-01 发布日期:2015-05-01
  • 作者简介:陈楚君(1992 –),女(汉族),湖北十堰人,硕士研究生,研究方向:中国刑法学。

Types of Concurrence of Law Articles and its Application Principle

Chen Chu - jun   

  1. Law School,Sichuan University,Chengdu Sichuan,610225,China
  • Online:2015-05-01 Published:2015-05-01

摘要:

法条竞合的本质是实质一罪、假性竞合,这一点区别于想象竞合之实质数罪、真正竞合的本质。明确界定法
条竞合的内涵和本质、厘清法条竞合的类型是正确适用处断原则的前提。法条竞合的类型应当从传统的纷繁复杂的
划分方法中寻找新的突破口,实现类型简明化。法条竞合属于法条关系论,而不是犯罪形态论,法条竞合的本质是构
成要件之间的竞合,据此可将法条竞合划分为三种类型:独立竞合、依附竞合、交叉竞合。其中独立竞合即传统上的特
别关系法条竞合,应当采用“特别法排斥普通法”的适用原则,摒弃“重法优于轻法”的补充原则。

关键词: 法条竞合, 想象竞合, 独立竞合, 依附竞合, 交叉竞合, 特别法, 普通法

Abstract:

The nature of concurrence of law articles is substantive one crime and false concurrence,which is different from
that of plural crimes in imagined concurrence and that of real concurrence. Clearly defining the connotation and essence of
concurrence of law article and clarifying the types of concurrence of law articles are the prerequisites for applying the principle
correctly. A new breakthrough is necessary for a concise categorization of types of concurrence of law articles. Concurrence of
law article is related to the theory of law relationship,rather than the theory of criminal pattern. The essence of concurrence of
law articles is concurrence between constituent elements,whereby concurrence of law articles can be divided into three types:
separate concurrence,attachment concurrence and cross concurrence. Separate concurrence which is traditionally called special
relationship concurrence of law article is applicable to the principles of“special law exclusion of common law”and abandon
the complementary principle of“serious punishment superior to light punishment”

Key words: concurrence of law articles, imagined concurrence, separate concurrence, attachment concurrence, cross competing,
special law,
common law