西南石油大学学报(社会科学版) ›› 2016, Vol. 18 ›› Issue (6): 84-89.DOI: 10.11885/j.issn.16745094.2016.10.28.01

• 文史哲论丛 • 上一篇    

《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》与乔姆斯基理论的再认识

李昊   

  1. 四川省社会科学院文学研究所, 四川 成都 610072
  • 收稿日期:2016-10-28 出版日期:2016-11-01 发布日期:2016-11-01
  • 作者简介:李昊(1978-),女(汉族),四川成都人,博士,助理研究员,研究方向:语言学、文学研究。

A New Angle to Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée and Chomsky's Theory

LI Hao   

  1. Institute of Chinese Literature, Sichuan Academy of Social Sciences, Chengdu Sichuan, 610072, China
  • Received:2016-10-28 Online:2016-11-01 Published:2016-11-01

摘要: 《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》是西方第一部关于传统语法理论的经典著作,乔姆斯基称其为转换生成语法理论的先驱,但学术界认为乔姆斯基的语法理论并非源于其启示。从哲学基础看,《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》的唯理论思想与笛卡尔哲学、乔姆斯基唯理论思想是有扬弃的继承,三者在“先验、理性、普遍”特征上是相通的。从语言观看,《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》与乔姆斯基理论研究的对象都是语法而非语言,主张语言学的任务是通过理性来发现深层的隐藏的组织原理。从方法论看,二者都充分运用逻辑与语言的关系,只不过在具体的逻辑方法上有异。从结构规则看,《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》所谓的名词和动词实际上是名词短语和动词短语。可以肯定,《波尔·罗瓦雅尔语法》对乔姆斯基理论具有重要的启发和先驱作用。

关键词: 《波尔·, 罗瓦雅尔语法》, 乔姆斯基, 转换生成语法, 语言, 传统语法理论

Abstract: Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée is the first classic piece of traditional grammar theory in the west, which had been forgotten for various reasons. After Chomsky claimed that it was a pioneer of transformational generative grammar, the book again attracted people's attention. In spite of Chomsky's high praise on it, the academic circles hold that Chomsky's grammar theory is not based on Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée. The author of this paper makes a comparison between these two theories and analyzes their relations. From a philosophical point of view,Chomsky's rationalism theory both inherited and abandoned the rationalism of Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée and Descartes' philosophy. All the three are interlinked in respects of transcendentalism, rationality and universality. From the linguistic viewpoint, the research object of this book and Chomsky theory is grammar rather than the language. They argue that the task of linguistics is to find deep and hidden organization principle by rationality. From the aspect of methodology, both of them fully use the relations between logic and language, different only in specific logical methods. The structural rules in Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée comply with Chomsky's phrase structure rules with nouns and verbs actually referring to noun phrases and verb phrases in Chomsky'. From what has been discussed above, we can conclude that Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée is an important inspiration and pioneer of Chomsky's transformational generative grammar.

Key words: Grammaire Générale et Raissonnée, Chomsky, transformational generative grammar, languge, traditional grammar theory

中图分类号: